Although woody biomass appears on the surface to be an excellent renewable energy source it, like all energy sources, has its drawbacks. As excerpts from an Oregon Public Broadcasting report below describes, energy generated from woody biomass requires feeding the plant with wood that is burned to produce energy while the fuel for solar is, for all intents and purposes, unlimited and without the potential negative consequences of burning wood to produce energy.
# # #
Central Oregon Sees Wood-Based Biofuels In Mixed Light
Ethan Lindsey – OPB News – January 17, 2008
Wood was probably mankind’s first energy source.
Now, some timber businesses see wood as a renewable source of energy that could give Oregon, and the Pacific Northwest, the kind of economic clout the oil-rich gulf states now have.
That future is a long way off.
Burning wood for energy simply isn’t financially worthwhile right now.
Nor is burning the wood hot enough to produce more profitable oil or biofuel.
But that hasn’t stopped the government, and other interest groups, from exploring the new business potential of what they call ‘woody biomass.’
Cal Mukumoto is the manager of Warm Springs Biomass, a subsidiary of the timber company owned by the Confederated Tribes of Warm Springs.
Cal Mukumoto: “It’ll be a while before this is a real good replacement.”
The Warm Springs tribe received a $250,000 grant from the federal government to develop a woody biomass power plant.
And Mukumoto, along with most companies thinking about biomass power, say they hope to build new plants in balance with the environment.
Cal Mukumoto: “That’s one of the reasons the Warm Springs tribe sized this plant a little smaller than what the supply said. We didn’t want this biomass plant to start saying ‘feed me’. It says it anyway, but we didn’t want it in a low voice.”
Phil Chang is the biomass program administrator for the Central Oregon Intergovernmental Council.
Phil Chang: “Basically we have all this forest thinning activity going on to reduce the risk of wildfire and restore forest ecosystems. And we have this choice between taking all this small woody biomass material, chopping it up into pieces and burning it up in the woods.”
He points out that unlike typical timber factories, woody biomass doesn’t need big, thick trees.
Asante Riverwind, the Sierra Club activist, says scale is why environmentalists aren’t embracing biomass like you might think they would because, although it seems like a green technology, the future could give the biomass business just as much financial clout as the rest of the timber industry at the expense of truly renewable energy.
Asante Riverwind: “Our biggest concern, among many, is that a lot of money and expenditures go into creating a biomass plant. So they have a big appetite. And what happens ten, twenty years done the line? Are we creating something similar to the mills around here, an insatiable appetite that’s going to be fed at a significantly harmful cost to the environment.”